JarSort · Inherited coin values

Coin dealer offer vs value — why the numbers differ

You look up your coin, the guide says $50, and the dealer offers $35. That gap is not a scam — it is how the coin trade works. But the size of the gap is where lowballs hide. Here is what each number actually means, with real Oct 2026 figures, so you can tell a fair offer from a bad one before you accept it.

The three numbers that matter

Prices as of Oct 24, 2026 · Silver spot $53.80/ozt (Kitco) · Circulated, common date, problem-free, raw (uncertified) unless stated

Example: Morgan dollar

$42–$68 retail

What a collector pays a dealer. Melt floor $41.61.

Dealer might pay

~$31–$37

Estimate inferred at 75–90% of melt — the dealer's buy price, not a firm bid.

The gap

20–50%+

Typical dealer margin below guide prices, per estate guidance. The gap is the dealer's profit, risk, and overhead.

Morgan figures Oct 24, 2026 (retail $42–$68; dealer-pay inferred from an observed Oct 18, 2026 buy/sell pair of $33.32 / $44.82). 1964 quarter: retail $10–$11 vs dealer ~$7.30–$8.75. All figures Oct 24, 2026.

Three different numbers, three different meanings

Melt floor — the metal value. Pure arithmetic: silver weight × spot price. A Morgan dollar holds 0.7734 ozt, so its floor is $41.61 at the Oct 24, 2026 spot of $53.80/ozt. No honest dealer goes far below this for a silver coin.
Retail / recent sold range — what a collector pays at the end of the chain, after the dealer has held, graded, and marketed the coin. A Morgan sells for $42–$68; a 1964 quarter for $10–$11.
Dealer-likely pay — what a dealer pays you. Common US silver runs about 75–90% of melt; collectibles about 60–70% of retail. No major dealer publishes a standing buy list, so these figures are estimates inferred from observed buy/sell pairs and published margin rules — never firm bids.

Why the dealer pays less

The dealer buys your coin, holds it, and resells it at a profit while carrying the risk that it sits in a case for a year. That margin pays rent, authentication, grading, and the coins that turn out to be cleaned, damaged, or fake. A fair offer sits inside the dealer-likely range; an offer far below melt for a silver coin is a lowball, whatever the guide price says.

How to get a fair offer

Know the melt floor first. It is the one number that cannot be argued with.
Get two offers. Take the dealer sheet to two dealers and compare them against the dealer-likely range.
Never accept the first number. Especially not on the day you inherited the coins.
Do not clean anything. Cleaning destroys value and gives a dealer a reason to cut the offer.
Certify the big ones. A key date in a certified holder (PCGS/NGC) is worth far more than the same coin raw, because the dealer does not have to price in authentication risk.

Do not clean your coins. Cleaning is the fastest way to destroy collector value — a polished coin can lose half its worth instantly, and no cleaning can be undone. Handle coins by the edges, keep them dry, and leave toning and dullness exactly as they are.

Sort your jar free — 3 free scansGuided identification, three sourced prices per coin, and a dealer sheet to take to two dealers.

No signup wall for your first coin. No AI photo recognition is claimed or used — you confirm year and mint mark yourself.